It’s been a little bit more than a year since I got my first PVR, and in my usual way I’ve managed to fill more than half of it up with stuff that I’m absolutely sure I’m going to review “real soon now”. Unfortunately the backlog is such that I think I’m going to merely do one big recommendation, just in case you find some of these items passing by in your television feed and a brief recommendation will tip the balance, or perhaps get you to add a title to your Netflix list (I don’t have Netflix; I have boxes of DVDs LOL).
I should mention that these films have all been on Turner Classic Movies since March 2013. If you don’t get TCM and you like old mysteries, this might be a good investment for you; TCM is not reluctant about re-running movies once every year or so. I liked all these films enough to hold onto them in the hopes of reviewing them someday; I will suggest that any of them will fill an idle hour, although your mileage may vary. I’m one of those people who enjoys bad movies but I understand that that taste is not universally shared.
Here’s what about 40% of my DVR’s storage capacity looks like:
- Three Perry Mason movies with Warren William: TCOT Howling Dog (1934), TCOT Lucky Legs (1935), TCOT Velvet Claws (1936). And with Ricardo Cortez, TCOT Black Cat (1936).
- Murder on the Blackboard (1934), and Murder on a Honeymoon (1935); Hildegarde Withers mysteries with Edna May Oliver. Murder on a Bridle Path (1936) with Helen Broderick as Miss Withers. The Plot Thickens (1936) and Forty Naughty Girls (1937), featuring ZaSu Pitts as Miss Withers
- The Thirteenth Chair (1937); Dame May Whitty plays a spiritualist who solves a murder.
- Detective Kitty O’Day (1944) and Adventures of Kitty O’Day (1944), where Jean Parker plays the titular telephone operator at a hotel who solves mysteries with her boyfriend, Peter Cookson.
- The Death Kiss (1933): Bela Lugosi is top-billed but only supports this story about an actor who’s killed while on set shooting a movie called “The Death Kiss”. I love backstage movies where the real camera pulls back to reveal a fake camera and crew shooting the movie within the movie!
- Having Wonderful Crime (1945): Pat O’Brien as J.J. Malone and George Murphy/Carole Landis as Jake and Helene Justus in a story based on a Craig Rice novel. And Mrs. O’Malley and Mr. Malone (1950), where James Whitmore plays J. J. Malone and, the script having been changed from Hildegarde Withers, Marjorie Main plays the earthy Mrs. O’Malley. (Her novelty song is worth the price of admission alone.)
- After the Thin Man (1936), Another Thin Man (1939), Shadow of the Thin Man (1941), and The Thin Man Goes Home (1944). Nick and Nora Charles (William Powell and Myrna Loy).
- Chained For Life (1952): Real-life conjoined twins Daisy and Violet Hilton have a vaudeville act, but when one murders the other’s husband, they both end up on trial. Yes, seriously. They sing and dance, not very well. The kind of movie that it sounds like much more fun to watch than it actually is, unfortunately.
- The Dragon Murder Case (1934), with Warren William as Philo Vance; The Casino Murder Case (1935), with Paul Lukas as Vance; The Garden Murder Case (1936), with Edmund Lowe as Vance; Calling Philo Vance (1940), with James Stephenson as Vance. And The Kennel Murder Case (1933), with William Powell as the best Vance of all.
- The Murder of Dr. Harrigan (1936), with Kay Linaker as the multi-named Sarah Keate (in this case, Sally Keating — from the Sarah Keate novels by Mignon Eberhart). Ricardo Cortez as the love interest.
- Sherlock Holmes (1922), starring John Barrymore in the famous silent.
- Miss Pinkerton (1932), with Joan Blondell as a sleuthing nurse from the novel by Mary Roberts Rinehart.
- Guilty Hands (1931), wherein Lionel Barrymore kills his daughter’s sleazy boyfriend.
- The Scarlet Clue (1945), with Sidney Toler as Charlie Chan investigating a murder at a radio station.
- Before Dawn (1933), a good old-fashioned Old Dark House film with Stuart Erwin and Dorothy Wilson as a beautiful young psychic.
- We’re on the Jury (1937), with Helen Broderick and Victor Moore as jurors on a murder case who comically take the law into their own hands.
- The Ex-Mrs. Bradford (1936), with William Powell and Jean Arthur as a sleuthing couple.
- Welcome Danger (1929), a comedy with Harold Lloyd investigating murders in San Francisco’s Chinatown.
- They Only Kill Their Masters (1972), with James Garner as a small-town lawman solving a murder with the help of veterinarian Katharine Ross.
- Seven Keys to Baldpate (1935), starring Gene Raymond in another remake of the Earl Derr Biggers thriller.
- Lady Scarface (1941), with Judith Anderson chewing the scenery as a cruel mob boss.
- Fast and Loose (1939), with Robert Montgomery and Rosalind Russell in one of the “bookseller” trilogy, each of which featured a different pair playing Joel and Garda Sloane.
- The Verdict (1946), with Sydney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre solving a mystery in Victorian London.
- Secrets of the French Police (1932); Gregory Ratoff is a mad hypnotist who runs a scam with Gwili Andre as the bogus “Tsar’s daughter”.
- Moonlight Murder (1936), with Chester Morris taking time off from being Boston Blackie to investigate a murder case during a performance of Il Trovatore at the Hollywood Bowl.
- Nancy Drew, Detective (1938), with Bonita Granville as the plucky teenage investigator.
Are any of these cherished films for you — or are any of them over-rated? Your comments are welcome.
Wow! I’d love to give your recommendations on soemfo these, but you’ve stumped me on many of these titles. Never heard of 75% of these. The Philo Vance, Hildegarde Withers, Perry Mason, Thin Man and Charlie Chan titles are, of course, all familiar, but I’ve seen none of them. In fact, I’ve seen only two of the movies in your long list — Barrymore as Holmes and the Doberman whodunit THEY ONLY KILL THEIR MASTERS notable for its *huge* surprise when the killer is revealed.
I went trolling YouTube hoping some of these would turn up. I found only a few and will download them later at home. I also watched a four minute clip of Dame May Whitty as the medium in THE THIRTEENTH CHAIR. That one looks like a lot of fun. Hope I can find it someday on the internet. I’m not a cable subscriber so I will never be able to record anything from TCM.